Reading David Hackett Fischers "Champlain's Dream"--
Some surprises:
- Mohawk Indians wore armor to their first battle with Champlain--wood slats linked with cotton thread. It reminds me of the armor Japanese warriors of the same period wore, though their slats were leather.. Fischer says it was effective against arrows with flint heads.
- They fought in closed ranks--in contrast to Champlain's handfull who fought from cover, a reversal of future patterns.
- The Mohawks had an impressive "castle", made of wood, but tall enough Champlain resorted to European siege tactics. See this.
- Early French plantations failed--Harshaw's rule. Scurvy was often a big problem, though winter hunting providing fresh meat during the winter would help.
- Fischer emphasizes the insecurity of the hunter-gatherer economy--tribes which lived by hunting lived well until the hunts failed, because of bad weather. It seems a response to those who believe agriculture was humanity's biggest mistake.
- I'm always struck by the scant clothing of native Americans (even more so the Taino Columbus encountered). Makes a difference in domestic economy and in lifestyle.
- I'm surprised by the ease and frequency of Champlain's trips to and from the New World. Ben Franklin and George Whitfield did a lot of crossings, but Champlain did 40+ trips, many quite fast. I'm not sure whether it's the improvements in ships between 1492 and 1610 or the learning process, likely both.
- It took 30 years or so for the French to establish themselves securely at Quebec and Montreal, with permanent settlements with French women.
- Fischer notes the early development of the voyageur culture, at least its earliest members among a group of young men who lived with various Indian nations/tribes for one or more winters, learning the language and the way of life, as well as other differences between the French and English patterns of dealing with native Americans.
No comments:
Post a Comment